Enamel vs. Acrylic Paint: Which One is Right for Your Craft?
Choosing the right paint for your next craft project can make all the difference in your results. Whether you're a seasoned DIYer or just starting out, understanding the basics of enamel versus acrylic paint will help you create lasting, beautiful pieces you can be proud of.
Table of contents
Understanding Enamel and Acrylic Paint
Before picking up a brush, it helps to know what sets acrylic and enamel paint apart. Both types have unique properties and best-use scenarios, which influence everything from finish to durability.
- Enamel paint is an oil-based or solvent-based product known for its durability and glossy finish. It’s commonly used for projects that need a tough, washable surface. Crafters often choose enamel for metal, glass, ceramics, or outdoor objects.
- Acrylic paint is water-based, quick-drying, and versatile. Its easy clean-up and wide color range make it popular for artists and hobbyists working on canvas, wood, paper, or fabric. Acrylic paint can be layered, mixed, and thinned with water.
Benefits of Acrylic Paint for Crafts
Stands out for several reasons, especially in the world of crafts. Here are some of the top benefits:
- Easy to Use: Can be applied with brushes, sponges, or even fingers. It dries quickly, allowing you to finish projects faster.
- Low Odor and Non-Toxic: Most are water-based and emits minimal fumes, making it appropriate for indoor use and for children’s crafts.
- Versatility: Acrylics adhere to various surfaces—wood, canvas, plastic, fabric, and more—with proper priming or preparation.
- Vibrant Colors: With a broad array of hues available, acrylic paint allows for bold, creative expression. It also blends well for custom shades.
- Simple Clean-Up: Since water-based, cleaning brushes and hands only requires soap and water.
When to Use Enamel Paint
Popular choice, enamel paint excels in certain situations:
- Superior Durability: Enamel paint forms a hard, protective shell when dry, making it ideal for items subject to heavy use or exposure.
- Glossy Finish: If your project needs a shiny, sleek appearance, enamel provides an often unmatched sheen.
- Moisture and Chemical Resistance: Enamel paint resists water and chemicals better than most water-based paints, so it’s perfect for painting outdoor crafts, kitchenware (not food-contact surfaces), or garden décor.
Comparing Finish and Appearance
When it comes to the look and feel of your final product, acrylic and enamel paint offer different results.
- Acrylic paint can appear matte, satin, or gloss, depending on the formulation or whether you add a varnish. It tends to have a softer finish and can be built up for texture. Acrylics also allow for a more painterly aesthetic and a variety of techniques.
- Enamel paint offers a classic, high-gloss finish that looks smooth and polished. It stands up well to cleaning and frequent handling, making it popular for model cars or decorative metal objects.
Drying Time and Application
Acrylic paint typically dries in minutes, making it ideal for projects that require multiple coats or detailing in a short time frame. You can layer colors without waiting for hours. Enamel paint, in contrast, needs longer to cure fully—sometimes several hours to a day—so patience is necessary.
Application methods also differ:
- Acrylic paint is forgiving and doesn’t streak much. Mistakes can be easily fixed with water before the paint sets.
- Enamel paint requires careful application to avoid brush marks. For best results, use synthetic brushes or a spray method.
Surface Preparation and Longevity
Surface preparation can make or break your project. Acrylic paint adheres best to clean, slightly textured surfaces. Priming may be needed if you’re working on glass, metal, or plastic. Enamel paint, on the other hand, requires a thoroughly clean, sometimes sanded surface for optimal adhesion.
In terms of longevity, enamel paint has an edge for high-wear or outdoor items. However, acrylic paint , especially with a protective clear coat, can offer great durability for display pieces or items not exposed to harsh elements.
Craft Project Examples
Not sure which way to go? Here are some common crafts and which paint works best:
- Canvas Art: Acrylic paint is the top pick for its layering ability and rich color options.
- Model Cars or Trains: Enamel paint’s tough finish is ideal for handling and realism.
- Decorative Flower Pots: Use acrylic paint indoors, but choose enamel if placing outdoors.
- Upcycling Furniture: Acrylic paint is user-friendly for most furniture, but enamel may be better for surfaces needing frequent cleaning.
Conclusion
By weighing the unique benefits and limitations of both acrylic and enamel paint , you can select the perfect option for your next craft. Consider your project’s surface, intended use, and desired look to achieve the best results.
Ready to start crafting? Choose the paint that matches your needs and let your creativity shine!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the difference between enamel paint and acrylic paint?
Enamel paint dries to a hard, glossy, and durable finish, while acrylic paint dries faster and is water-based, flexible, and easy to clean up. Enamel is great for long-lasting projects; acrylic is ideal for quick crafts and beginners.
Which paint lasts longer: enamel or acrylic?
Enamel paint is typically more durable and long-lasting, especially on items exposed to wear or moisture. Acrylic paint is durable too but may need sealing for maximum longevity.
Is enamel or acrylic paint better for beginners?
Most beginners prefer acrylic paint because it dries fast, is water-soluble, and easy to fix or layer. Enamel paint offers a more professional, glossy look but requires longer dry times and more ventilation.
Recent posts
Check out our YouTube and Pinterest and Instagram pages.
https://www.linkedin.com/in/katie-may-8771921a7/
Hi, I’m Katie May! I’m the owner of DIY Craft Warehouse, a woman-owned, family-run business in Brecksville, Ohio. I’m a maker at heart — crafting tumblers, vinyl projects, and custom gifts — and that hands-on experience guides how I choose products, support customers, and lead our company. After seeing how tough it could be to find affordable, high-quality supplies, I partnered with my mom, Debbie, to build a place where creators could get the tools, guidance, and inspiration they need. Today, I focus on spotting new trends and bringing in products that help makers turn creativity into profit. DIY Craft Warehouse is more than a business to me — it’s a community. I love connecting with creators, hearing their ideas, successes, and struggles, and helping them craft with confidence. Outside of work, I’m a big Cleveland sports fan and spend my fall and winter coaching volleyball at both the high school and club level. When I'm not at a game or in the gym, you’ll find me hanging out with my dog, Archie, who’s always up for an adventure or a good couch cuddle.
- Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
!